i love simon cowell! he is so honest and also brought one of the most watched shows to america!

alyjah at 5:18PM on Jan 25th 2008

Sometimes I really can't stand some of the things Simon says. They're so mean. But I just love how honest he is, overall. More people should be just as honest in this world.

Meaghan at 5:45PM on Jan 25th 2008

No I think he is toatly honest

Greensoftballchick at 6:52PM on Jan 25th 2008

simon is so funny! hes really honest, but he can be a little mean

bookwrm95 at 1:00PM on Jan 26th 2008

I thnk that simon can be brutal at some points. But he can be really mean.

carolinaman at 1:33PM on Jan 26th 2008

simon, not my favorite of the judges but yes he is honest although heres somthing simon should hear"THE TRUTH SOMETIMES HURTS" i think simon could tone down a bit but then agian what would american idol be with out simon?! I LOVE AMERICAN IDOL!!!

kylii at 3:16PM on Jan 26th 2008

He is so honest that he is kinda mean... but he speaks tha truth...

kaylie28 at 3:32PM on Jan 26th 2008

i personally think that simon is the funnyest guy ever but everything he says is sooooo true!!!
thats what makes em GREAT!!! :):)

c3c3:) at 6:55PM on Jan 26th 2008

he definetly gets paid to be so mean i think he should have some pity on the bad singers

james teller at 7:05PM on Jan 26th 2008

i personally luv simon. he says wat evry1 else is thinkn they just dont want 2 b rude. he doesnt care. i wanna b kinda like that. not that meen but stil. and b sides hes 1 of the funniest ppl in hollywood without a script in front of them.

sarah at 10:11PM on Jan 26th 2008

i think he is funny but mean. I mean last year he made somone cry.

JohnDeereKidE at 11:24AM on Jan 27th 2008

I hate simon i dont care if he is funny he is just plain mean people have the courage to try out for American idol then he just brings them down even if they did bad he can at least say "good try"

Amelia at 11:33AM on Jan 27th 2008

I think he is so mean to some of them.He should give them some advice,not laugh and be rude.

Krista at 12:25PM on Jan 27th 2008

Hes just plain rude to people!

Krista at 12:26PM on Jan 27th 2008

Simon is awesome. Some of those "singers" are in denile about how truly awful they sound.

He is the only reason to watch the show.

Alyse at 2:37PM on Jan 27th 2008

Don't you think simon is just alittle 2 mean? I mean he does not need to be so rude.

Brandi at 3:13PM on Jan 27th 2008

alyjah sorry but simon didnt make the show it was simon fuller that made the show and thats a whole dif person. i do agree though that simon COWELL is honest on the show.

Jennifer at 4:37PM on Jan 27th 2008

I think that if it wasn't for Simon somone that sucks would win American Idol. So leave him alone, we wouldn't want the wrong person to get the record deal.

SaRaH at 10:00PM on Jan 27th 2008

We don't want someone that sucks to win American Idol, right? So leave him alone and let Simon do his job.

SaRaH at 10:06PM on Jan 27th 2008

I love simon he hates stupid people that think they can sing like i do haha

hahaha at 12:08PM on Jan 28th 2008