Last night, in an 'American Idol' shocker, 38 million voters sent 24-year-old Carly Smithson packing. Carly wowed the judges with her rendition of 'Superstar,' from Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical 'Jesus Christ Superstar,' but the majority of viewers weren't impressed.

Brooke White had to begin her song again after a false start, but America clearly forgave the snafu. "It must be a bit of a popularity week in the vote," Randy Jackson said.

Carly's departure leaves just five young hopefuls in contention for the top spot.